Letter from the Editor –Lindsay Preston Zappas
Parasites in Love –Travis Diehl
To Crush Absolute On Patrick Staff and
Destroying the Institution
–Jonathan Griffin
Victoria Fu:
Camera Obscured
–Cat Kron
Resurgence of Resistance How Pattern & Decoration's Popularity
Can Help Reshape the Canon
–Catherine Wagley
Trace, Place, Politics Julie Mehretu's Coded Abstractions
–Jessica Simmons
Exquisite L.A.: Featuring: Friedrich Kunath,
Tristan Unrau, and Nevine Mahmoud
–Claressinka Anderson & Joe Pugliese
Buy the Issue In our Online Shop
Reviews April Street
at Vielmetter Los Angeles
–Aaron Horst

Chiraag Bhakta
at Human Resources
–Julie Weitz

Don’t Think: Tom, Joe
and Rick Potts

at POTTS
–Matt Stromberg

Sarah McMenimen
at Garden
–Michael Wright

The Medea Insurrection
at the Wende Museum
–Jennifer Remenchik

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Mike Kelley
at Hauser & Wirth
–Angella d’Avignon
Letter from the Editor –Lindsay Preston Zappas
The Briar and the Tar Nayland Blake at the ICA LA
and Matthew Marks Gallery
–Travis Diehl
Putting Aesthetics
to Hope
Tracking Photography’s Role
in Feminist Communities
– Catherine Wagley
Instagram STARtists
and Bad Painting
– Anna Elise Johnson
Interview with Jamillah James – Lindsay Preston Zappas
Working Artists Featuring Catherine Fairbanks,
Paul Pescador, and Rachel Mason
Text: Lindsay Preston Zappas
Photos: Jeff McLane
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Children of the Sun
at LADIES’ ROOM
– Jessica Simmons

Derek Paul Jack Boyle
at SMART OBJECTS
–Aaron Horst

Karl Holmqvist
at House of Gaga, Los Angeles
–Lee Purvey

Katja Seib
at Château Shatto
–Ashton Cooper

Jeanette Mundt
at Overduin & Co.
–Matt Stromberg
Letter From the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Green Chip David Hammons
at Hauser & Wirth
–Travis Diehl
Whatever Gets You
Through the Night
The Artists of Dilexi
and Wartime Trauma
–Jonathan Griffin
Generous Collectors How the Grinsteins
Supported Artists
–Catherine Wagley
Interview with
Donna Huanca
–Lindsy Preston Zappas
Working Artist Featuring Ragen Moss, Justen LeRoy,
and Bari Ziperstein
Text: Lindsay Preston Zappas
Photos: Jeff McLane
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Sarah Lucas
at the Hammer Museum
–Yxta Maya Murray

George Herms and Terence Koh
at Morán Morán
–Matt Stromberg

Hannah Hur
at Bel Ami
–Michael Wright

Sebastian Hernandez
at NAVEL
–Julie Weitz

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Alex Israel
at Greene Naftali
–Rosa Tyhurst

Trulee Hall's Untamed Magic Catherine Wagley
Ingredients for a Braver Art Scene Ceci Moss
I Shit on Your Graves Travis Diehl
Interview with Ruby Neri Jonathan Griffin
Carolee Schneemann and the Art of Saying Yes! Chelsea Beck
Exquisite L.A. Claressinka Anderson
Joe Pugliese
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Ry Rocklen
at Honor Fraser
–Cat Kron

Rob Thom
at M+B
–Lindsay Preston Zappas

Soul of a Nation: Art in the Age
of Black Power, 1963-1983
at The Broad
–Matt Stromberg

Anna Sew Hoy & Diedrick Brackens
at Various Small Fires
–Aaron Horst

Julia Haft-Candell & Suzan Frecon
at Parrasch Heijnen
–Jessica Simmons

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Shahryar Nashat
at Swiss Institute
–Christie Hayden
Letter From the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Letter to the Editor
Men on Women
Geena Brown
Eyes Without a Voice
Julian Rosefeldt's Manifesto
Christina Catherine Martinez
Seven Minute Dream Machine
Jordan Wolfson's (Female figure)
Travis Diehl
Laughing in Private
Vanessa Place's Rape Jokes
Catherine Wagley
Interview with
Rosha Yaghmai
Laura Brown
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring: Patrick Martinez,
Ramiro Gomez, and John Valadez
Claressinka Anderson
Joe Pugliese
Buy the Issue In our Online Shop
Reviews Outliers and American
Vanguard Art at LACMA
–Jonathan Griffin

Sperm Cult
at LAXART
–Matt Stromberg

Kahlil Joseph
at MOCA PDC
–Jessica Simmons

Ingrid Luche
at Ghebaly Gallery
–Lindsay Preston Zappas

Matt Paweski
at Park View / Paul Soto
–John Zane Zappas

Trenton Doyle Hancock
at Shulamit Nazarian
–Colony Little

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Catherine Opie
at Lehmann Maupin
–Angella d'Avignon
Letter From the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Celeste Dupuy-Spencer and Figurative Religion Catherine Wagley
Lynch in Traffic Travis Diehl
The Remixed Symbology of Nina Chanel Abney Lindsay Preston Zappas
Interview with Kulapat Yantrasast Christie Hayden
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring: Sandra de la Loza, Gloria Galvez, and Steve Wong
Claressinka Anderson
Photos: Joe Pugliese
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Raúl de Nieves
at Freedman Fitzpatrick
-Aaron Horst

Gertrud Parker
at Parker Gallery
-Ashton Cooper

Robert Yarber
at Nicodim Gallery
-Jonathan Griffin

Nikita Gale
at Commonwealth & Council
-Simone Krug

Lari Pittman
at Regen Projects
-Matt Stromberg

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Eckhaus Latta
at the Whitney Museum
of American Art
-Angella d'Avignon
Letter From the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Letter to the Editor Julie Weitz with Angella d'Avignon
Don't Make
Everything Boring
Catherine Wagley
The Collaborative Art
World of Norm Laich
Matt Stromberg
Oddly Satisfying Art Travis Diehl
Made in L.A. 2018 Reviews Claire de Dobay Rifelj
Jennifer Remenchik
Aaron Horst
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring: Anna Sew Hoy, Guadalupe Rosales, and Shizu Saldamando
Claressinka Anderson
Photos: Joe Pugliese
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews It's Snowing in LA
at AA|LA
–Matthew Lax

Fiona Conner
at the MAK Center
–Thomas Duncan

Show 2
at The Gallery @ Michael's
–Simone Krug

Deborah Roberts
at Luis De Jesus Los Angeles
–Ikechukwu Casmir Onyewuenyi

Mimi Lauter
at Blum & Poe
–Jessica Simmons

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Math Bass
at Mary Boone
–Ashton Cooper

(L.A. in N.Y.)
Condo New York
–Laura Brown
Poetic Energies and
Radical Celebrations:
Senga Nengudi and Maren Hassinger
Simone Krug
Interior States of the Art Travis Diehl
Perennial Bloom:
Florals in Feminism
and Across L.A.
Angella d'Avignon
The Mess We're In Catherine Wagley
Interview with Christina Quarles Ashton Cooper
Object Project
Featuring Suné Woods, Michelle Dizon,
and Yong Soon Min
Lindsay Preston Zappas
Photos: Jeff McLane
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Meleko Mokgosi
at The Fowler Museum at UCLA
-Jessica Simmons

Chris Kraus
at Chateau Shatto
- Aaron Horst

Ben Sanders
at Ochi Projects
- Matt Stromberg

iris yirei hsu
at the Women's Center
for Creative Work
- Hana Cohn

Harald Szeemann
at the Getty Research Institute
- Olivian Cha

Ali Prosch
at Bed and Breakfast
- Jennifer Remenchik

Reena Spaulings
at Matthew Marks
- Thomas Duncan
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Museum as Selfie Station Matt Stromberg
Accessible as Humanly as Possible Catherine Wagley
On Laura Owens on Laura Owens Travis Diehl
Interview with Puppies Puppies Jonathan Griffin
Object Project Lindsay Preston Zappas, Jeff McLane
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Dulce Dientes
at Rainbow in Spanish
- Aaron Horst

Adrián Villas Rojas
at The Geffen Contemporary at MOCA
- Lindsay Preston Zappas

Nevine Mahmoud
at M+B
- Angella D'Avignon

Radical Women: Latin American Art, 1960- 1985
at the Hammer Museum
- Thomas Duncan

Hannah Greely and William T. Wiley
at Parker Gallery
- Keith J. Varadi

David Hockney
at The Metropolitan Museum of Art (L.A. in N.Y.)
- Ashton Cooper

Edgar Arceneaux
at Yerba Buena Center for the Arts (L.A. in S.F.)
- Hana Cohn
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Barely Living with Art:
The Labor of Domestic
Spaces in Los Angeles
Eli Diner
She Wanted Adventure:
Dwan, Butler, Mizuno, Copley
Catherine Wagley
The Languages of
All-Women Exhibitions
Lindsay Preston Zappas
L.A. Povera Travis Diehl
On Eclipses:
When Language
and Photography Fail
Jessica Simmons
Interview with
Hamza Walker
Julie Wietz
Reviews Cheyenne Julien
at Smart Objects

Paul Mpagi Sepuya
at team bungalow

Ravi Jackson
at Richard Telles

Tactility of Line
at Elevator Mondays

Trigger: Gender as a Tool as a Weapon
at the New Museum
(L.A. in N.Y.)
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Object Project
Featuring: Rosha Yaghmai,
Dianna Molzan, and Patrick Jackson
Lindsay Preston Zappas
Photos by Jeff McLane
Pacific Standard Time: LA/LA
Reviews
Regen Projects
Ibid Gallery
One National Gay & Lesbian Archives and MOCA PDC
The Mistake Room
Luis De Jesus Gallery
the University Art Gallery at CSULB
the Autry Museum
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Women on the Plinth Catherine Wagley
Us & Them, Now & Then:
Reconstituting Group Material
Travis Diehl
The Offerings of EJ Hill
Ikechukwu Casmir Onyewuenyi
Interview with Jenni Sorkin Carmen Winant
Letter to the Editor Lady Parts, Lady Arts
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Object Project
Featuring: Rebecca Morris,
Linda Stark, Alex Olson
Lindsay Preston Zappas
Photos by Jeff McClane
Reviews Mark Bradford
at the Venice Biennale

Broken Language
at Shulamit Nazarian

Artists of Color
at the Underground Museum

Anthony Lepore & Michael Henry Hayden
at Del Vaz Projects

Home
at LACMA

Analia Saban at
Sprueth Magers
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Kanye Westworld Travis Diehl
@richardhawkins01 Thomas Duncan
Support Structures:
Alice Könitz and LAMOA
Catherine Wagley
Interview with
Penny Slinger
Eliza Swann
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring:
taisha paggett
Ashley Hunt
Young Chung
Intro by Claressinka Anderson
Portraits by Joe Pugliese
Letter to the Editor
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Reviews Alessandro Pessoli
at Marc Foxx

Jennie Jieun Lee
at The Pit

Trisha Baga
at 356 Mission

Jimmie Durham
at The Hammer

Parallel City
at Ms. Barbers

Jason Rhodes
at Hauser & Wirth
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Generous
Structures
Catherine Wagley
Put on a Happy Face:
On Dynasty Handbag
Travis Diehl
The Limits of Animality:
Simone Forti at ISCP
(L.A. in N.Y.)
Ikechukwu Casmir Onyewuenyi
More Wound Than Ruin:
Evaluating the
"Human Condition"
Jessica Simmons
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring:
Brenna Youngblood
Todd Gray
Rafa Esparza
Intro by Claressinka Anderson
Portraits by Joe Pugliese
Reviews Creature
at The Broad

Sam Pulitzer & Peter Wachtler
at House of Gaga // Reena Spaulings Fine Art

Karl Haendel
at Susanne Vielmetter

Wolfgang Tillmans
at Regen Projects

Ma
at Chateau Shatto

The Rat Bastard Protective Association
at the Landing
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Kenneth Tam
's Basement
Travis Diehl
The Female
Cool School
Catherine Wagley
The Rise
of the L.A.
Art Witch
Amanda Yates Garcia
Interview with
Mernet Larsen
Julie Weitz
Agnes Martin
at LACMA
Jessica Simmons
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring:
Analia Saban
Ry Rocklen
Sarah Cain
Intro by Claressinka Anderson
Portraits by Joe Pugliese
Reviews
Made in L.A. 2016
at The Hammer Museum

Doug Aitken
at The Geffen Contemporary at MOCA

Mertzbau
at Tif Sigfrids

Jean-Pascal Flavian and Mika Tajima
at Kayne Griffin Corcoran

Mark A. Rodruigez
at Park View

The Weeping Line
Organized by Alter Space
at Four Six One Nine
(S.F. in L.A.)
Letter form the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Non-Fiction
at The Underground Museum
Catherine Wagley
The Art of Birth Carmen Winant
Escape from Bunker Hill
John Knight
at REDCAT
Travis Diehl
Ed Boreal Speaks Benjamin Lord
Art Advice (from Men) Sarah Weber
Routine Pleasures
at the MAK Center
Jonathan Griffin
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Exquisite L.A.
Featuring:
Fay Ray
John Baldessari
Claire Kennedy
Intro by Claressinka Anderson
Portraits by Joe Pugliese
Reviews Revolution in the Making
at Hauser Wirth & Schimmel

Carl Cheng
at Cherry and Martin

Joan Snyder
at Parrasch Heijnen Gallery

Elanor Antin
at Diane Rosenstein

Performing the Grid
at Ben Maltz Gallery
at Otis College of Art & Design

Laura Owens
at The Wattis Institute
(L.A. in S.F.)
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Moon, laub, and Love Catherine Wagley
Walk Artisanal Jonathan Griffin
Reconsidering
Marva Marrow's
Inside the L.A. Artist
Anthony Pearson
Mystery Science Thater:
Diana Thater
at LACMA
Aaron Horst
Informal Feminisms Federica Bueti and Jan Verwoert
Marva Marrow Photographs
Lita Albuquerque
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Interiors and Interiority:
Njideka Akunyili Crosby
Char Jansen
Reviews L.A. Art Fairs

Material Art Fair, Mexico City

Rain Room
at LACMA

Evan Holloway
at David Kordansky Gallery

Histories of a Vanishing Present: A Prologue
at The Mistake Room

Carter Mull
at fused space
(L.A. in S.F.)

Awol Erizku
at FLAG Art Foundation
(L.A. in N.Y.)
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Le Louvre, Las Vegas Evan Moffitt
iPhones, Flesh,
and the Word:
F.B.I.
at Arturo Bandini
Lindsay Preston Zappas
Women Talking About Barney Catherine Wagley
Lingua Ignota:
Faith Wilding
at The Armory Center
for the Arts
and LOUDHAILER
Benjamin Lord
A Conversation
with Amalia Ulman
Char Jansen
How We Practice Carmen Winant
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Share Your Piece
of the Puzzle
Federica Bueti
Amanda Ross-Ho Photographs
Erik Frydenborg
Reviews Honeydew
at Michael Thibault

Fred Tomaselli
at California State University, Fullerton

Trisha Donnelly
at Matthew Marks Gallery

Bradford Kessler
at ASHES/ASHES
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
Hot Tears Carmen Winant
Slow View:
Molly Larkey
Anna Breininger and Kate Whitlock
Americanicity's Paintings:
Orion Martin
at Favorite Goods
Tracy Jeanne Rosenthal
Layers of Leimert Park Catherine Wagley
Junkspace Junk Food:
Parker Ito
at Kaldi, Smart Objects,
White Cube, and
Château Shatto
Evan Moffitt
Melrose Hustle Keith Vaughn
Reviews Mary Ried Kelley
at The Hammer Museum

Tongues Untied
at MOCA Pacific Design Center

No Joke
at Tanya Leighton
(L.A. in Berlin)
Snap Reviews Martin Basher at Anat Ebgi
Body Parts I-V at ASHES ASHES
Eve Fowler at Mier Gallery
Matt Siegle at Park View
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Max Maslansky Photographs
Monica Majoli
at the Tom of Finland Foundation
White Lee, Black Lee:
William Pope.L’s "Reenactor"
Travis Diehl
Dora Budor Interview Char Jensen
Letter from the Editor Lindsay Preston Zappas
MEAT PHYSICS/
Metaphysical L.A.
Travis Diehl
Art for Art’s Sake:
L.A. in the 1990s
Anthony Pearson
A Dialogue in Two
Synchronous Atmospheres
Erik Morse
with Alexandra Grant
SOGTFO
at François Ghebaly
Jonathan Griffin
#studio #visit
with #devin #kenny
@barnettcohen
Mateo Tannatt
Photographs
Jibade-Khalil Huffman
Buy the Issue In Our Online Shop
Slow View:
Discussion on One Work
Anna Breininger
with Julian Rogers
Reviews Pierre Huyghe
at LACMA

Mernet Larsen
at Various Small Fires

John Currin
at Gagosian, Beverly Hills

Pat O'Niell
at Cherry and Martin

A New Rhythm
at Park View

Unwatchable Scenes and
Other Unreliable Images...
at Public Fiction

Charles Gaines
at The Hammer Museum

Henry Taylor
at Blum & Poe/ Untitled
(L.A. in N.Y.)
Distribution
Downtown
A+D Museum
Artbook @ Hauser & Wirth
Baert Gallery
Central Park
Cirrus Gallery
Château Shatto
Elevator Mondays
The Geffen Contemporary 
at MOCA
OOF Books @ Warehouse
François Ghebaly
ICA LA
JOAN
LACA
LADIES' ROOM
The Mistake Room
MOCA Grand Avenue
Monte Vista Projects
Murmurs
Nicodim Gallery
Night Gallery
Royale Projects
The Box
Vielmetter Los Angeles
Wilding Cran Gallery
Boyle Heights/ Chinatown
A.G. Geiger
Bel Ami
Charlie James
Good Luck Gallery
Human Resources
Parrasch Heijnen Gallery
Eastside
ESXLA
Folding Days @ Eightfold Coffee
Odd Ark LA
River Gallery
Smart Objects
Women's Center for Creative Work
Westside
18th Street Arts
Ben Maltz Gallery at Otis
Crap Eyewear
DXIX Projects
Five Car Garage
LA Louver
Laband Art Gallery at LMU
Pasadena/ Glendale/ Valley
The Armory Center for the Arts
The Pit
Los Angeles Valley College
Mid-City
1301 PE
As-Is Gallery
California African American Museum
Chimento Contemporary
Commonwealth & Council
David Kordansky Gallery
Hammer Museum
Hunter Shaw Fine Art
Kayne Griffin Corcoran
Lowell Ryan Projects
ltd Los Angeles
Ochi Projects
Park View / Paul Soto
Praz-Delavallade
the Landing
Shoot the Lobster
SPRÜTH MAGERS
The Underground Museum
USC Fisher Museum of Art
Visitor Welcome Center
Culver City
Anat Ebgi
Arcana Books
Blum & Poe
Honor Fraser
Klowden Mann
Philip Martin Gallery
Roberts Projects
Hollywood
AA|LA
Bridge Projects
Diane Rosenstein
Family Books
LACE
LA> LSH CoLAB
M+B
Nino Mier Gallery
Nonaka-Hill
Moskowitz Bayse
Noysky Projects
Regen Projects
Shulamit Nazarian
Steve Turner
Tanya Bonakdar Gallery
The LODGE
Various Small Fires
Mobile
Gas Gallery
@gasdotgallery
Non-L.A.
CLOACA (San Francisco, CA)
Et al. (San Francisco, CA)
Ever Gold [Projects] (San Francisco, CA)
fused space (San Francisco, CA)
Interface Gallery (Oakland, CA)
Jessica Silverman (San Francisco, CA)
Left Field (Los Osos, CA)
McNally Jackson (New York, NY)
Minnesota Street Projects (San Francisco, CA)
San Diego Art Institute (San Diego, CA)
Santa Barbara City College (Santa Barbara, CA)
Skowhegan School of Painting and Sculpture (Skowhegan, ME)
Ulises (Philadelphia, PA)
Verge Center for the Arts (Sacramento, CA)
Wattis Institute for Contemporary Art (San Francisco, CA)
Whitney Museum Shop (New York, NY)
Wolfman Books (Oakland, CA)
Libraries/ Collections
Bard College, Center for Curatorial Studies Library (Annandale-on-Hudson, NY)
CalArts (Valencia, CA)
Center for the Arts, Wesleyan University (Middletown, CT)
Cranbrook Academy of Art (Bloomfield Hills, MI)
Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Research Library (Los Angeles, CA)
Los Angeles Contemporary Archive (Los Angeles, CA)
Marpha Foundation (Marpha, Nepal)
Maryland Institute College of Art, The Decker Library (Baltimore, MD)
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Thomas J. Watson Library (New York, NY)
Midway Contemporary Art (Minneapolis, MN)
Museum of Contemporary Art Santa Barbara, Emerging Leaders of Arts (Santa Barbara, CA)
Northwest Nazarene University (Nampa, ID)
NYS College of Ceramics at Alfred University, Scholes Library (Alfred, NY)
Pepperdine University (Malibu, CA)
Point Loma Nazarene University (San Diego, CA)
School of the Art Institute of Chicago, John M. Flaxman Library (Chicago, IL)
Skowhegan Archives (New York, NY)
Sotheby’s Institute of Art (New York, NY)
Telfair Museum (Savannah, GA)
University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA)
University of San Diego (San Diego, CA)
USC Fisher Museum of Art (Los Angeles, CA)
Walker Art Center (Minneapolis, MN)
Whitney Museum of American Art, Frances Mulhall Achilles Library (New York, NY)
Yale University Library (New Haven, CT)

Parasites in Love

Rosemarie Trockel, The Critic (2015). Mixed media, 67 x 23.75 x 23.75 inches. © Rosemarie Trockel. Image courtesy of Matthew Marks Gallery. Photo: Aaron Wax.

I understand why folks get such schadenfreude out of puckish work like Jasper Johns’ The Critic Sees (1961)—a gray brick with eyeglasses and mouths where the eyes should be. It’s a good joke. But I enjoyed it more before I started writing criticism. Johns, who has said he made the piece as a retort to a needling critic,1 belongs to a generation that saw critics as snobs and bloodsuckers, subsisting on artists’ nutritious ooze, and so refused to see the critics in themselves. Another, more recent “critical” work, Rosemarie Trockel’s The Critic (2015), cuts closer to the truth. It’s a realistic sculpture of a young woman in black clothes with a pot full of Alpine goat beards perched on her head, her hair rolled into large curlers. She has been out for scalps. What makes this sculpture honest is that Trockel’s mannequin looks a lot like her.

Both of these sculptures appeared in a 2019 show at Matthew Marks Gallery in New York called The Critic—a perennial subject, maybe because it pricks the professional anxieties of everyone involved. The gray specter of The Critic, courtesy of Greenberg, still represents a certain soul-breaking view of the art market, with its winners and (mostly) losers. Also in 2019, the poet and critic Raphael Rubinstein wrote a searching article about the dwindling audience for old-fashioned art criticism (while citing new collections of essays by art critics like Peter Schjeldahl and Chris Kraus). He wrote that “however brilliant a piece of criticism might be, it will always be secondary to that art that inspired it.”2 To me, this rings like critics’ most nagging doubt about what we do—that criticism is superfluous, and no one cares. It also sounds like the kind of viewpoint that Schjeldahl describes in his latest book as one of those “dreary, timid, deadening attitudes toward art, of kinds that have changed in form but that never die.”3 

To argue that art is primary but writing is not, you need to believe that art is original—the way a baby thinks they are the first person on earth. Perhaps birth is the start of the conflict between originality and repetition that Rosalind Krauss described in “The Originality of the Avant-Garde” (1981), and why we value the former, not the latter. “The self as origin is safe from contamination by tradition because it possesses a kind of originary naiveté,” Krauss wrote. Forty years later, art’s originality remains a comforting fantasy, the way the American Dream still whispers that you are different, unique enough to make your own fortune—just like everybody else. This isn’t a coincidence. The self-starting, bohemian vigor of the historical avant-garde has prototyped the modern gig worker with their brand of one. In that social-Darwinist vision, it’s the overpromised, underdelivered, final state of comfort and success that makes life worth living.

In fact, it’s this existential pressure that pits artists and critics against one another, while also muddling their individual virtues into some idea of a “creative class.” In that mindset, artists and critics (and curators and gallerists and collectors) can only commit to the obvious capitulation of high art to worldliness, no longer dreaming of escaping the ivory tower so much as, like the basement-dwelling family in the movie Parasite, just hoping for a gig in a fancy house. That hope is addictive. Even Greenberg wrote of the golden umbilical cord that ties artists to the real nourishment, issued by that big, wealthy, bloated—but still throbbing— body of capital. The artist and the critic and billions of others are united in their hunger. 

But that’s not the whole story. Yes, critics do rely in a very real way on the work of others. But artists also respond to the world—which includes other art. As Trockel’s sculpture reminds us, the artist and the critic often share a body. Schjeldahl’s book ends with an essay on Oscar Wilde’s “The Critic as Artist” (1890). The Socratic pundit in Wilde’s dialogue thinks that those who can’t do, critique. But Wilde argues that both artists and critics share a common “critical faculty” to tear down the old and invent the new. “The tendency of creation is to repeat itself,” wrote Wilde, but “it is the critical faculty that invents fresh forms.”4 Clearly, the Greenbergian style of art writing has given way to a livelier, more equally distributed discourse on apps and online magazines, undertaken by people in all areas of the arts. In a sense, what defines the artist is a certain performance of originality, while the critic plays their role as an omnivorous student of existing information. (“Criticism is in large part a performing art,” writes Schjeldahl.)5 The difference between the two is vocational: intelligent, critical thinkers playing their respective roles. Krauss notes that Rodin, even as he promoted himself as an originary genius, worked in multiples.6

Art in the age of mechanical reproducibility is the art of reference, of context, of interaction—from appropriation to relational to research-based forms, and on up. For Oscar Wilde, unoriginality is a virtue for those concerned with what he calls an “intellectual relation to their age.”7 We’ve got to work with what we’ve got. DIS, a millennial collective that spans art, fashion, and media, has learned this lesson well. When they curated the Berlin Biennale in 2016, they packaged the sacred original in the language of advertising. The work they selected looked like it belonged in its venues year-round—a juice bar by Débora Delmar Corp. (a company of one) in the lobby of an art academy; displays about blockchain by Simon Denny in a business school. DIS and the ambivalence they exhibited not only tweaked critics’ anxieties about the relevance of their own form, but also the anxiety of artists, apparently doomed to play the role of your average white-collar entrepreneur. 

“Couched in airy naïveté and ironic enthusiasm,” wrote critic and artist Hannah Black, the biennial embraced the parameters of “a world dominated visually, ethically, and ontologically by capital, in which long-standing forms of struggle—the protest, the union, the political party, even critique—seem like nostalgic curiosities or reenactments, ultimately doomed to fail.”8 The pursuits that Black identifies as outdated on capitalism’s terms are versions of the “moral imperative” Schjeldahl attributes to the critic-as-artist, and—along with art—remain ways of orienting yourself critically to the world: ways not of taking but of giving back. 

DIS’ biennial was a cynical, pragmatic attempt not to burn down the system, but to climb inside capitalism’s ruined body and keep warm. Art and criticism are both food for that survival: acts meant to be taken up, discussed, dissected, digested, used—and made again—from one parasite to another. Relegating the critic to a secondary role, the artist to a primary one, might help to keep the order of events intact—the art is made, the critic responds—but any question of hierarchy between the arts, however off-handed, obscures the common cause of responding to our age. It so happens that our moment, our new form of old trouble, is one that rewards some over others, making our relationships antagonistic and competitive, while at the same time compressing our roles into soulless full-time jobs. We work and think and live in an age that is fighting against understanding and resisting its own analysis, by rewarding ignorance and cynicism over curiosity and love.

“Art critics are generally poets who have betrayed their art,” wrote Robert Smithson, a failed poet himself, in Artforum. Critics of this kind try to “turn art into a matter of reasoned discourse” and, when that fails, they “resort to a poetic quote.”9 Art criticism as we know it has its roots in ekphrastic poetry, verse written on the occasion of the experience of art. The first critics were actual poets: Baudelaire in the 19th century; Auden and O’Hara in the mid-20th. Schjeldahl gave up writing poetry decades ago; Bruce Hainley continues the tradition today, while other critics, like Hannah Black and Travis Jeppesen, are writers and novelists in a similarly poetic vein. What these forms of making and writing share is a critical relationship to the contemporary. Capitalism wants us to think capitalism is all that we have in common. In fact, artists and critics are both adept at thinking beyond the crushing, pragmatic logic of the contemporary itself—the way a parasite might live, for a moment, without a host.

Travis Diehl has lived in Los Angeles since 2009. He is a recipient of the Creative Capital / Andy Warhol Foundation Arts Writers Grant (2013) and the Rabkin Prize in Visual Art Journalism (2018).

This essay was originally published in Carla issue 19.

Débora Delmar Corp, MINT (installation view) (2016). Juice bar, furniture, prints. Image courtesy of Debora Delmar Corp.; DUVE Berlin; and the 9th Berlin Biennale for Contemporary Art. Photo: Timo Ohler.
Débora Delmar Corp, MINT (installation view) (2016). Juice bar, furniture, prints. Image courtesy of Debora Delmar Corp.; DUVE Berlin; and the 9th Berlin Biennale for Contemporary Art. Photo: Timo Ohler.
Christopher Kulendran Thomas, New Eelam (installation view) (2016). Mixed media, developed in collaboration with Annika Kuhlmann. Film Production: Klein and West, Mark Reynolds. Design: Manuel Bürger, Jan Gieseking. Architecture: Martti Kalliala. Production Design: Marcelo Alves. Biosphere: Matteo Greco. Creative Director: Annika Kuhlmann. Image courtesy of Christopher Kulendran Thomas; New Galerie, Paris. Photo: Laura Fiorio.
  1. Emma Brockes, “Master of Few Words,” The Guardian, July 26, 2004, https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2004/jul/26/art.usa.
  2. He makes an exception for “agenda criticism,” with axes to grind and discourses to shape. In that case, though, the art is secondary to the critic’s own (still secondary) mission. Raphael Rubinstein, “The Ghosts of Art Criticism,” Art in America, October 2019, https://www.artnews.com/art-in-america/features/where-is-the-audience-for-art-criticism-now-63661.
  3. Peter Schjeldahl, “Credo: The Critic as Artist: Updating Oscar Wilde,” Hot, Cold, Heavy, Light (New York: Abrams, 2019), p. 374.
  4. Quoted in Schjeldahl, p. 375.
  5. Schjeldahl, p. 378.
  6. Rosalind Krauss, “The Originality of the Avant-Garde: A Postmodernist Repetition,” October, Fall 1981, pp. 47–66.
  7. Quoted in Schjeldahl, p. 376.
  8. Hannah Black, “The 9th Berlin Biennale,” Artforum, September 2016, https://www.artforum.com/print/reviews/201607/the-9th-berlin-biennale-63010.
  9. Robert Smithson, “A Sedimentation of the Mind: Earth Proposals,” Artforum, September 1968, pp. 44–50.